Mediation in North America

An Examination of the Profession's Cultural Premises

Mediation in North America: An Examination of the Profession’s Cultural Premises
"Our mistake is to assume that what is 'logical' and works in one setting can be directly transferred to another."

The primary purpose [of this paper] is to reflect on the premises and assumptions implicit in the interaction model generally adopted by North American mediation experts and proposed in their “doctrinal” materials as the proper way of managing conflict.

This is a study of the “subculture” of professional mediation. It will clarify how their definitions of the situation may produce crucial points of tension when directly exported to other cultures. It will also suggest key factors to be considered as mediation moves from one cultural setting to another, in and outside of the United States. As a point of reference, North American assumptions about the use of a third party will be compared with Latin American conceptions. Differences between them that may produce cultural dissonances will be examined by looking at what happens when one model of mediation is exported from this context to theirs…

This is a Comprehensive Examination Paper submitted to the Sociology Department of the University of Colorado, Boulder.

Lederach, John Paul. “Mediation in North America: An Examination of the Profession’s Cultural Premises.” Comprehensive Examination Paper. Boulder, Colorado, Spring 1986.

Shared with the permission of the MCC Library and the library collections of MCC Canada and MCC U.S.

read

Once downloaded, PDFs can be translated via Google Translate

connect

situate this material in the web of John Paul's vocational reflections

explore

related items you might be interested in

The Challenge of Terror: A Traveling Essay

Written while stranded in Guatemala after September 11, an essay suggesting a number of lessons learned from peace initiatives where terrorism was employed as a tool of struggle and calling for new approaches to combating the challenge.

A Wish For The Future

An article imagining a courageous alternative to the then pending U.S. war with Iraq.

Local Mediation: A Transformative Approach to Conflict in Nepal

An article describing the emergence and transformative impact of a community mediation program in Nepal.